Agamemnon helmet by Nolan compared to Batman rendition
Rants

How Nolan’s Odyssey May Change Films Forever

Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey film may be a tipping stone with tremendous silver lining. Let me explain.

Fake poster for The Odyssey showing scifi Warhammer armor to illustrate how silly the armor looks in the trailer

The internet came around in the ’90s. Now information is at everyone’s fingertips, including history and historically-accurate dress, which means more than ever before the public eye knows how inaccurate most historical films really look, especially their combat scenes with all their sword flailing and spinning around like ballerinas, and so public expectation for accuracy, or at least respect for history, will only grow larger as information spreads, just like it did for classical studies in medieval times upon the invention of the printing press.

Movie poster featuring Mel Gibson as William Wallace from 'Braveheart', showcasing dramatic medieval imagery and a powerful quote.

If you think blatant misrepresentation of the past is just a small nerdy complaint because “it’s only a fantasy story” then you’re wrong. Civilizations operate best under shared narratives with respect for their foundations, and so altering public perception via art can profoundly shape the cultural identity of nations just like Homer’s Odyssey actually did when the poem was shared around ancient hearths!

Comparison of two depictions of Caracalla: a historically accurate statue on the left and a character portrayal from 'Gladiator 2' on the right.

If Nolan’s movie sells poorly or even gets many terrible reviews then it will hopefully be a canary call for movies with historical settings moving forward, because satisfying your audience is how Hollywood makes the big bucks and, as seen with recent viral posts on X, people are very dissatisfied (although admittedly the movie isn’t officially released yet upon writing this):

Just embrace the Greek-themed sci-fi world instead of insulting everyone who has an education in classical studies, please Nolan. I respect your career tremendously, but enough is enough and we need more filmmakers on the side of truth. It’s time to make films great again.

The Trojan Horse in Odyssey vs Trojan Horse in Troy movie which used boat parts because it's cool

Modern films do shape public perception and have been spreading way too many misconceptions, fantasy or not. If it’s historically inspired it will warp the way we view our past and suck away proper understanding of the foundations of Western civilization, because the Odyssey is a cornerstone of Western civilization (hence why this is so insulting [try getting away with this doing The Bible movie {we’ve all seen how bad The Last Supper ceremony in the 2024 Paris Summer Olympics went}]).

White culture holocaust example showing DEI hire Helen in Nolan's Odyssey compared to Helen in Troy

Enough is enough!!!! It feels like mockery at this point.

I do appreciate that the film may gain people’s interest in exploring the real past like medieval fantasy did for me as a youth, but a film that pays respect to historical settings would do this much better because it would bring people closer to the truth, not closer to rewatching The Dark Knight, lol. For instance, we’ve all met people who say the arms and armor in the Game of Thrones TV show are “realistic”, and that’s clearly manipulation of perception even if unintentional (the books are way better!).

Agamenón 2026 from The Odyssey compared to Agamenón 2004 from Troy

I would have no reason to complain if Nolan had just made a Warhammer-style film set in an alternative universe inspired by ancient Greece, but basing this off the Odyssey is what irks me because with a $250 million dollar budget this could have been such an aesthetically elegant film! Instead, we have what appears to be plastic, 3D-printed slop enhanced by AI slop to make a compounding slop-fest.

chicken-claw helmet from Alexander Nevsky 1938
Example of creative liberty that is still aesthetically elegant and based on historical records – chicken-claw helmet from Alexander Nevsky 1938

I’ll say it again though that the silver lining is that this film might be a tipping stone. If public outcry can make movies less woke (thank God), then we can make historically inspired films great again like they were back in the early and mid 20th century.

My rant is over, sorry for the cringe. Not sorry.

Before you go check out this version of Nolan’s trailer edited by DemonFlyingFox on YouTube and tell me in the comments which version looks better.


Discover more from The Medieverse: Tim's Realistic "medieval" FANTASY Blog

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Speak your mind freely (comments with links will be manually approved ASAP)

Discover more from The Medieverse: Tim's Realistic "medieval" FANTASY Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading